WA Mining
WA gold and lithium boom party may be over
Gold has lost about 8% in a week and lithium has roughly halved since May. WA's miners are hurting on the sharemarket, but most are still making money in the ground. It's not 2015 again. Yet.
Gold: off a cliff this week
Gold kept sliding on Friday, down about 2.4% to around US$3,540 an ounce by late morning Perth time. That's roughly 8% lower than a week ago, and its worst week since March. The ASX's gold index fell around 4% and was heading for its eighth losing session in a row (Market Index).
It follows a brutal Thursday. Perth-based Northern Star, the country's biggest gold miner, fell 5.7%, and the ASX gold index lost 5.6% (ad-hoc-news). Bullion is now about 22% below its January record near US$5,318, and on track for its worst year since 2015 (Startup Fortune, citing Kitco).
Why it is falling. Traders now expect the US Federal Reserve to keep lifting interest rates, possibly into 2027. Gold pays no interest, so higher rates make it less attractive. The US dollar is also near its strongest level in 19 months, which weighs on anything priced in dollars (Kitco). Investors are also selling metals broadly as they pull back from trades tied to artificial intelligence and data centres, and weak Chinese data has added to the pressure (Inshorts).
WA gold miners today
- Loading live prices…
ASX prices, delayed about 20 minutes.
Is the party over in Kalgoorlie?
Not yet. The share-price falls look dramatic, but the maths at the mine gate is still healthy. In Australian dollars, gold is still around A$5,300 an ounce, because the weaker Aussie dollar softens the blow.
Northern Star's all-in sustaining cost in the September quarter was A$3,217 an ounce (Kalkine). At today's price that still leaves a margin of roughly A$2,000 on every ounce, more than WA producers made through most of the past decade.
The risk sits with higher-cost and smaller producers, and with projects whose numbers were drawn up at last year's record prices. If gold keeps falling, expect project delays and tighter exploration budgets well before job cuts at the big Goldfields operations.
Lithium: from boom to surplus, again
Lithium's fall has been steeper. Spodumene, the concentrate WA mines produce, has almost halved from its May high of about US$3,000 a tonne (ABC News); spot is now around US$1,220. In China, lithium carbonate futures have slid from about 210,000 yuan a tonne in May to around 90,000 this week, according to charts shared by market analyst Carl Capolingua.
Citi this month cut its price targets for the big ASX lithium miners by 27% to 29%, warning the global market is likely to flip from shortage to surplus by 2027. It still prefers PLS (formerly Pilbara Minerals), pointing to its low costs and A$2.2 billion in cash, while IGO's Kwinana lithium hydroxide refinery continues to weigh on that company's earnings (Proactive).
Which WA mines are underwater
Citi has mapped what it costs to run six Australian spodumene mines, which together supply about a quarter of the world's lithium. In the September quarter they sold at an average of about US$2,030 a tonne, down 11% on the June quarter, and every one of them still made a cash margin. Spot prices are now about 40% below that average.
At today's price, Citi calculates only three still cover their all-in sustaining costs: Greenbushes near Bunbury, PLS's Pilgangoora and Wodgina, both in the Pilbara. Liontown's Kathleen Valley near Leinster, and Mineral Resources' Mt Marion near Kalgoorlie and Bald Hill near Kambalda, do not. Once spending on expansions is counted, Pilgangoora's margin shrinks to about 5%. Citi's commodities team expects prices of about US$1,250 a tonne in 2027, barely above today, and says there is little cost support under current prices. It remains cautious on lithium, with PLS still its preferred stock (Citi research, shared by Rudi Filapek-Vandyck).
WA lithium miners today
- Loading live prices…
ASX prices, delayed about 20 minutes.
There are still signs of confidence. In October, PLS committed more than A$1 billion to expand its Pilgangoora mine in the Pilbara, promising around 1,500 jobs, even as prices fell (ABC News). Low-cost producers like Pilgangoora and Greenbushes can ride out a downturn. Higher-cost mines and the state's downstream processing ambitions are more exposed, as the 2024 slump showed when several WA lithium operations were mothballed.
It's not 2015 again. Yet.
In 2015, gold and iron ore fell together, WA's royalties shrank and the state slid into a mining downturn that hit Perth's jobs and house prices for years. This time is different, for now. Iron ore, WA's biggest earner, has held up, gold miners are still well in the black, and no major layoffs have been announced.
- Jobs: the first signs to watch are paused expansions, slower hiring of fly-in, fly-out crews and cuts to exploration.
- The state budget: lower prices mean lower royalties. Gold and lithium are small next to iron ore, but a long slump would show up in the state's books.
- Your super: WA miners are a big slice of the ASX, so most Perth super balances will feel this week's falls.
This story is for general information only and is not financial advice. Live gold, iron ore and WA stock prices are in Perth by the Numbers.
Perth's business, property and markets news, plus what's on this weekend. Free, every Friday at 6am.